Who've done it?

Suggest your forum game ideas here.

Who've done it?

Postby Nutkiplit809 » 5 February 2017, 09:55

This is a game 'Who've done it?'. Its based of a party game Mafia.
The instructions are very important. Sorry for letting you read this for too long.


Illustrations are shown after 1 'day'.

How to play

10 players will say /join to enter the game.
I will PM each player on who will either the Killer, Medic, Townsperson, or the Sheriff

--

Objective

The Killer's objective is to kill everyone.
The Medic's objective is to prevent the Killer from killing the selected person
The Townspeople's objective is to point out who is the Killer
The Sherrif's objective is to find out who is the Killer
Lying is allowed

--

How it goes

Everyone will 'fall asleep'.
Ill PM the Killer and he will PM back who he wants to kill
Then, ill PM the Medic and tell him who to save
After, ill PM the Sheriff on who he/she think is the Killer

--

When someone is dead

Everyone will 'wake up'
Then, all of them will figure out who is the Killer
Everyone shall vote who will be executed
When someone have the highest votes, they will be executed
When 2 or more people have the same votes, they will reason out that if they are/not the Killer
Then, again the people will vote among the people who is the Killer
When someone is executed, I will tell what role are they
If they execute the wrong person, they will be eliminated and wait for another round
The Killer still lives and the same procedure goes on

YOU CANT TELL WHAT ROLE ARE YOU PLAYING AS. EVEN AT CHAT, GAME, etc.

--

When the Killer is dead, the round ends and ill wait for another 10 people

--

When the Medic is dead, no one can be saved

--

When the Sheriff is dead, the Townspeople should accuse randomly

--

When the Killer is still alive and there are 2 people remaining, the Killer wins
Last edited by Nutkiplit809 on 8 February 2017, 14:26, edited 2 times in total.
User avatar
Nutkiplit809
Civil Security Lite [100]
 
Posts: 130
Joined: 23 April 2016, 11:44

Re: Who've done it?

Postby Dariy » 5 February 2017, 11:38

So you watched the edge games thing :P
/join if this is gonna be a thing
User avatar
Dariy
Advanced Usurpation Soldier [150]
 
Posts: 158
Joined: 6 November 2013, 21:43
Location: ѕιттιηg ση α яαιηвσω ωιтн α ѕтяιηg αяσυη∂ му ƒιηgєя

Re: Who've done it?

Postby Nutkiplit809 » 5 February 2017, 11:41

Dariy wrote:So you watched the edge games thing :P
/join if this is gonna be a thing


Yes, I found out Mafia off of Team Edge

Dont join yet. You can if this is published at the Games Area
User avatar
Nutkiplit809
Civil Security Lite [100]
 
Posts: 130
Joined: 23 April 2016, 11:44

Re: Who've done it?

Postby chrose » 5 February 2017, 13:37

Sorry, but I don't see this taking off.

The townsmen will basically be nothing but a bloodthirsty mob throwing accusations without any proof other than their "gut feeling", not to mention how boring it would be to play as one. The sheriff role is just a glorified townsmen without any actual abilities. The medic and killer are the only ones that have an actual impact on the game.

In the end, this is just a dumbed-down, much slower version of Town of Salem. If you want to play something like this, gather a group of people and play ToS.
User avatar
chrose
RtD Enthusiast
 
Posts: 28
Joined: 1 December 2016, 19:03
Location: Antarctica

Re: Who've done it?

Postby Resi » 30 April 2017, 00:10

chrose wrote:In the end, this is just a dumbed-down, much slower version of Town of Salem. If you want to play something like this, gather a group of people and play ToS.


You do realize that Town of Salem is based on the Mafia Party Game which existed many years ago before BlankMediaGames executed their game horribly, right?

Also the OP is horrible, it doesn't describe the rules or instructions well, plus the main problem of the forums is activity which is the Mafia Party Game's most needed and important factor.
User avatar
Resi
Lite Marine [800]
 
Posts: 833
Joined: 16 July 2013, 00:47
Location: Venezuela

Re: Who've done it?

Postby chrose » 3 May 2017, 00:54

silverteen11 wrote:
chrose wrote:In the end, this is just a dumbed-down, much slower version of Town of Salem. If you want to play something like this, gather a group of people and play ToS.


You do realize that Town of Salem is based on the Mafia Party Game which existed many years ago before BlankMediaGames executed their game horribly, right?


I do, but my point still stands. This version of Mafia proposed by Nutkip IS dumbed down, and slower than ToS. There is no reason to play this version over BMG's, however bad you think ToS is.
User avatar
chrose
RtD Enthusiast
 
Posts: 28
Joined: 1 December 2016, 19:03
Location: Antarctica

Re: Who've done it?

Postby Resi » 3 May 2017, 03:53

chrose wrote:
silverteen11 wrote:
chrose wrote:In the end, this is just a dumbed-down, much slower version of Town of Salem. If you want to play something like this, gather a group of people and play ToS.


You do realize that Town of Salem is based on the Mafia Party Game which existed many years ago before BlankMediaGames executed their game horribly, right?


I do, but my point still stands. This version of Mafia proposed by Nutkip IS dumbed down, and slower than ToS. There is no reason to play this version over BMG's, however bad you think ToS is.


I don't even think that ToS is bad, ToS being bad is a fact, there are many reasons to do so, if Nutkiplit properly writes the OP that is.
User avatar
Resi
Lite Marine [800]
 
Posts: 833
Joined: 16 July 2013, 00:47
Location: Venezuela


Return to Suggestions Area

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users